There’s concern that many sustainable funds, which have grown immensely over the past five years, have been mislabelled, leading to a regulatory crackdown expected to continue into 2023.
Greenwashing threatens credibility of asset managers
Environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues have expanded into the mainstream of the corporate world in recent years, and an increasing number of asset managers now offer ESG-labelled investment products. However, ‘greenwashing’, in which the environmental claims made do not match reality and are designed to deliberately mislead consumers, can cause enormous reputational damage and threatens to discredit the corporate world in general.
Even some of the largest and most renowned firms can succumb to accusations of greenwashing as they strive to establish their ESG credentials. Half the carbon offsets held by British Gas owner Centrica were recently found to be ‘junk credits’ that were issued under a discredited scheme. Meanwhile, the world’s biggest consumer bank, HSBC, was forced to pull an ad campaign in the United Kingdom after the advertising watchdog ruled that HSBC was touting a tree-planting scheme to offset carbon without acknowledging that it finances fossil-fuel projects at the same time.
In early 2023, Bloomberg said that greenwashing may be the biggest risk to the future of ESG investing. Yet, the agency added, there’s no firm agreement on what it means in a legal or regulatory context. Bloomberg added that ‘it’s typically used when companies, people or governments overstate, misrepresent or just plain lie about their climate credentials.’ 1
Too many grey areas
The lack of a common definition of greenwashing among the regulatory authorities makes it difficult to stamp out the practice. Bloomberg quotes Maia Godemer, a London-based sustainable finance analyst at BloombergNEF, as saying:
‘The battle to stamp out greenwashing continues to be foiled by the lack of a clear and common definition across jurisdictions. The market can only continue to flourish if regulators build a common framework around what is considered environmentally or socially sustainable.’
Bloomberg adds that while policymakers in Europe have been the most aggressive in trying to flesh out such a framework, the region’s market watchdog, the European Securities and Markets Authority, still struggles to specifically describe what greenwashing is.
EU leads the charge against greenwashing
Nonetheless, efforts to combat the practice have already had a dramatic effect, with many asset managers forced to stop claiming levels of sustainability in investments that don’t meet the new standard. During the second half of 2022, huge asset managers such as Amundi and BlackRock ceased claiming that US$140 billion worth of their funds qualified for the EU’s top ESG designation, known as Article 9.
Fund managers have downgraded more than $140bn in ESG assets
Not what it says on the tin
Regulators in the US and the UK are also investigating ESG funds amid concerns that asset managers are simply renaming existing products rather than building new ones, prompting doubts about the authenticity of the ESG claims made by these funds.
In the US, asset managers have reassessed trillions of dollars in sustainable investments, stripping them of their previously reported ESG status, according to the US Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment (US SIF). According to a report published by the association in December 2022, sustainable-investing assets in the US plunged by more than half as a result, from US$17.1 trillion at the end of 2019 to US$8.4 trillion at the end of 2021.2
US SIF says this more cautious approach was at least partly triggered by recent US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) proposals to crack down on greenwashing by raising standards on names and disclosure requirements for ESG funds.
The shakeout is likely to continue in 2023 as regulators and consumers press for improved transparency of funds. Improving asset managers’ credentials in this area can only be positive for the continued long-term growth of the sector, while a failure to address these concerns risks discrediting the sector entirely.
1 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-11/what-s-the-legal-definition-of-greenwashing-green-insight?leadSource=uverify%20wall
2 https://www.corporateknights.com/category-finance/u-s-sustainable-investing-assets-plunge-by-more-than-us8-trillion/
Publication date:
The information and opinions on this report are provided for general information purposes only. IG Bank S.A. do not guarantee, explicitly or implicitly, that the information and opinions are accurate, reliable, up-to-date or exhaustive. Furthermore, this report may contain IG Bank S.A. external analyst’s judgment, future expectations, views or opinions, but actual developments and results may differ materially from such expectations, in particular due to a number of risks, uncertainties and other factors. Such statement may subject to alteration without notice.
The information contained in this report should in no event be construed as a solicitation or offer, as advice or as a recommendation to implement or liquidate an investment or to carry out any other financial transaction, and it does not constitute any legal or tax advice. It should not be used as a basis for any investment decision or other decision. IG Bank S.A. accept no liability for any loss or damage of any nature whatsoever, whether direct, indirect or consecutive, arising from accessing, using, consulting its report or navigating its website, or from links to other report and/or websites. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information. Consequently any person acting on it does so entirely at their own risk. Any research provided does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any specific person who may receive it and as such is considered to be a marketing communication.
Contact us
Let us create a solution tailored for your needs. Get in touch with our team by phone or email to discuss your objectives, or request a brochure.